Carnival of Souls (1962)
Dec. 24th, 2020 07:36 amMovie: Carnival of Souls (1962), directed by Herk Harvey
You know the whole thing about Turkey Burnout, right? Like, Thanksgiving dinner is triple-thumbs-up Grade-A awesome, and Thanksgiving leftovers are somehow even better—for maybe the first couple of days. By about the third day in, though, the very notion of eating any more turkey makes you want to spatchcock yourself, drag your splayed carcass into a preheated oven, and let the gods gnaw on your wings ’n’ drumsticks. Well, watching ThanksKilling definitely filled me with a little too much turkey, if you catch my drift, so I thought tonight I should chow down on a classic—ideally something, you know, good. So I loaded up Carnival of Souls, which I hadn’t seen for ages and thought might make for a nice palate-cleanser. 
Watched on: HBO Max
Ran: 5.76 miles, 9’46”/mile, 56:18 (slow recovery run)

Mary Henry isn’t exactly what you’d call a “people person,” so who knows what she’s doing in a car with a couple of drag racers? Maybe she considers it a vague relief when their car plunges off a bridge into the river. In any case, the local authorities haven’t yet recovered the vehicle when Mary emerges from the water three hours later, with no memory of the accident. Just one of those things, I guess. And no time to dwell on trivial things like mysteriously surviving a deadly crash—it’s time to bail on this one-horse town forever and start her glamorous new job as a church organist in Salt Lake City! So she packs up her car and hits the road.
Unfortunately, Mary’s being haunted by visions of a wild-eyed powdery-looking dude in dire need of a tan, a good dandruff shampoo, and probably a pulse. He appears floating outside her car window going 60, standing in the middle of the highway, hovering outside her 2nd-floor boarding house window, etc.… and of course no one else ever sees him. Furthermore, she’s experiencing weird spells of seeming nonexistence, where nothing in the world makes a sound and no one seems to see or hear her. Sounds like she’s got enough on her plate without also having to contend with the unwelcome attentions of the guy across the hall, as well as her weird fixation on the abandoned carnival just outside of town. Does it have anything to do with her utter lack of desire for human companionship and her (gasp!) SECULAR ATTITUDE toward her church gig?
Poor Mary’s just trying to get on with her solitary lifestyle, but the increasing terror of being stalked by Corpsey Dude and occasionally fading from existence is making that tricky. She even tries to stomach a date with her loathsome and leering neighbor just to have some protection nearby, but that goes about as well as you’d expect, and eventually she winds up drawn back to the carnival for the creepy nightmare climax. Overall, Carnival of Souls feels a little like a super-long Twilight Zone episode, except I doubt Rod Serling would ever have produced such a predictable and unsatisfying ending. Without explicitly spoiling anything, I’ll just say that once you’re maybe ten minutes in, what you think is going on is pretty much exactly what’s going on.
Ultimately, though, maybe it’s not such a big deal, since Carnival of Souls isn’t really about the narrative—it’s about the atmosphere. Corpsey Dude is at least Freak Factor 11, and the nonexistence sequences are straight out of your most uncomfortable anxiety dreams. The cinematography is surprisingly effective—the starkness of the black and white makes everything a nightmare, and some of the shots (particularly in the carnival itself) are gorgeously disturbing. Even some of the scene transitions feel like those dreams when you suddenly find yourself impossibly elsewhere but it seems natural enough at the time.
Beyond the nightmare feel, to me the real horror in Carnival of Souls is Mary’s plight as society keeps trying to cast her in roles she’s not interested in playing. There’s something charmingly old-fashioned about all the community uproar over Mary’s indifference to the church and her lack of desire for a husband, but it’s not so alien that we don’t feel her claustrophobia at the pressure to sacrifice her preferences for her safety. It’s dreadful to see Mary on a date with her actual stalker just so she’s not alone and at the mercy of her spectral stalker. (Personally, given that date, I think she’d be better off with Corpsey Dude.) I’d actually be very interested in seeing a modern remake—not the reportedly execrable 1998 one, which had almost nothing in common with the original beyond the title—that was a more explicitly feminist reading of the original plot.
While it’s not the scariest movie out there, I do like Carnival of Souls, though I feel some of the fanboy worship for it might be a bit overblown. If you want a general creepfest that’s very much of its time and you aren’t much bothered by stories in which not a lot really happens, give it a whirl, especially if you’re a fan of low-key surreal cinematography. It’s definitely not a turkey—although, apropos of nothing, I feel it’s worth noting that when the film was over, HBO Max suggested “more like this” and the first movie listed was Pokémon: Detective Pikachu. Make of that what you will.
