ThanksKilling (2009)
Nov. 26th, 2020 10:57 pmMovie: ThanksKilling (2009), directed by Jordan Downey
You rolled your eyes at Halloween on Halloween… You gazed in heavy-lidded ennui at Friday the 13th on Friday the 13th… But nothing could prepare you for the shocking lack of creative initiative that is… ThanksKilling on Thanksgiving: (Pilgrim) Hat Trick! Yes, folks, if you thought I was going to come up with something original or clever to watch after forcing down Field Roast en croûte, Parker House rolls, mashed potatoes, gravy, cranberry sauce, roasted rainbow carrots with shiitake mushrooms and Brussels sprouts, Thanksgiving vegan slurry (comprising stuffing, macaroni and cheese, cranberries, and mushroom gravy), and butterscotch cinnamon pie with a ginger snap crust, you’re even dozier than I was, and I was in a carb coma so deep it was impractical to measure it in fathoms. 
Watched on: Amazon Prime
Ran: 7.03 miles, 9’37”/mile, 01:07:43 (slow recovery run)

And yet, somehow I still dragged my carcass onto the treadmill and got seven miles under my straining belt. How, you ask? Well, I can’t be certain, but I suspect the fundamental badness of ThanksKilling should claim at least partial credit for keeping me in a perpetual state of disbelief as to just what the hell I was looking at. When I read the description on Amazon Prime—“a homicidal turkey axes off college kids during Thanksgiving break”—I knew I wasn’t exactly in for a Kurosawa marathon. But what I was not prepared for was that the aforementioned homicidal turkey TALKS. Indeed, he swears a blue streak and cracks dumb one-liners. It’s a whole thing.
Let’s break down ThanksKilling like my digestive tract is breaking down all those starches into simple sugars to make my pancreas freak out: it starts, simply enough, with naked pilgrim boobs. The historical-times pilgrim lady to whom they belong is running from a demonic turkey, who kills her with a tomahawk. Cut to the present day, and five college students—two or three of whom probably shouldn’t have graduated middle school—are carpooling back to their home town for Thanksgiving. But the car breaks down, so they have to camp out for the night, which is when Darren (“the nerd”) tells them the campfire story of a demonic turkey summoned forth by Native American magic to kill as many white people as possible every 500-odd years. That seems like a really long time between vengeance-slaughters, but far be it from me to question the wisdom of the ancients.
You will be gobsmacked to learn, I am sure, that tonight is the night of the turkey’s semimillennial rampage, and from that point on, ThanksKilling has all the typical elements of your standard homicidal talking turkey story: turkey taunts kids in the woods; turkey shoots guy in the head and steals his car; turkey murders kids’ parents; turkey rapes college girl before breaking her neck; turkey fools local sheriff by wearing Groucho glasses; turkey cuts off sheriff’s face and wears it as an impenetrable disguise; etc. etc. etc. In other words, no big surprises. Meanwhile, our remaining carpool heroes are working to crack the secret to killing the invincible magic turkey, there’s a subplot with a hermit with a shotgun who wants to avenge the death of his dog, and, predictably enough, a convenient container of radioactive waste figures heavily in the climax.
ThanksKilling was thrown together for a few thousand bucks by literal college kids, and it shows: the acting is basically college students reading lines, the script is full of running JonBenét Ramsey gags and references to ghost-riding the whip, and the effects are scraped together from whatever they could find at Family Dollar—the exception being the turkey puppet, which is actually pretty dope. ThanksKilling isn’t the worst film I’ve ever seen—not by a LONG shot—but it’s among the worst I’ve watched since starting this whole Running Scared nonsense, which is saying something. And therein lies a dilemma, and an updated Zen koan: if a film is bad in the woods and nobody is around to watch it, does it still suck? Or, more to the point, if a film is bad on purpose and everybody expects and wants it to be, is it still a bad film?
So while I acknowledge that ThanksKilling is probably an objectively worse movie than, say, Can’t Take It Back (which I gave my lowest rating to date), intent matters, as does budget and general access to resources. Furthermore, ThanksKilling was honestly better than the other lowest-rated movie, Verotika, which not only made less narrative sense and had about equally poor acting, effects, and general production value, but also clearly TRIED TO BE GOOD and, worse yet, thought it had succeeded.
To bottom-line it for you, though, I wouldn’t expect many people to think ThanksKilling is fun to watch unless they’re dedicated schlock fans or either stoned or too full of gravy and pie to change the channel. Am I glad I watched it? Sure. Will I watch it again? Probably not, but never say never.
Will I watch the sequel? Tune in next Thanksgiving to find out.
